GST Unplugged:
From popcorn to policies!
GST Unplugged:
From popcorn to policies!
In the recent 55th GST Council Meeting, a lot of new reforms to the GST laws were made. The particular reform that dealt with the taxation of popcorn caused a lot of social media backlash. In a nutshell, this reform stated that popcorn will be taxed differently based on the sugar content it has, namely:
5% for loose popcorn with salt and spices.
12% for prepackaged and labeled popcorn
18% for caramel popcorn. (The logic behind this was that anything with sugar in it was to be considered sweet, similar to candy, and was to be taxed similarly)
Other miscellaneous changes included the combo bought at a theatre also having 12% GST applied if the movie ticket had a GST rate of 12%
Since the introduction of GST, it has been mired in controversy, with many critics lambasting it for adding complexity and bureaucratic red tape to an already opaque system. Introduced in July 2017, through the implementation of the One Hundred and First Amendment to the Constitution of India by the Government of India, GST replaced existing multiple taxes levied by the central and state governments. There was immense contention during its initial implementation due to the prevailing belief that the government was trying to merely rebrand the current taxation system. It was also argued that the GST would increase existing rates on common daily goods while reducing rates on luxury items, and affect many Indians adversely, especially the middle, lower middle and poorer income groups.
Goods and services are divided into 5 different tax slabs for tax collection: 0%, 5%, 12%, 18% and 28%. However, petroleum products, alcoholic beverages, and electricity are not taxed under GST but separately by the individual state governments, as per the previous tax system. These regulations are promulgated by a body called the GST Council, which has 33 members, out of which two members are from the center, and 31 members are from 28 states and 3 Union territories with Legislature. The council is headed by the Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, who is assisted by the finance minister of all the states of India. Ever since the introduction of GST, the revenue coming in from it has been increasing steadily, the graph below displays the same:
The above graph shows the GST collected in 2023 vs 2024. The amount collected has increased across the span of a year. In fact, since its inception in 2017, the trend of total GST collected has always been upward
A graph contrasting the GST revenue for two consecutive financial years. Again, a predominantly upward trend is seen
The inherent complexity and mutability of these GST laws, as represented by the proposed changes above, have sparked debates online and among political competitors. Jairam Ramesh, leader and spokesman of the main opposition Congress party said the "absurdity of three different tax slabs for popcorn under GST...only brings to light a deeper issue that the growing complexity of a system that was supposed to be a Good and Simple Tax
Netizens found the lengths to which the government would go to tax the population hilarious, and as soon as the news about the new tax laws came in, social media started getting flooded with memes, trolls, and even hate comments related to this incident.
An overwhelmingly negative reaction was seen on the GST laws
The Indian finance minister, Nirmala Sitharaman, was given the nickname ‘Nirmala Tai’ and was the main victim of all the criticism. Many laughed at the complexity of the new laws, some on the absurd statements made by Nirmala in public, while others commented on the absurdity of the niche laws set in place.
Many skits, re-enactments and AI/edited photos of Nirmala also became popular. A few examples are shown below:
Mumbai-based comedian, Radha, who goes by Radha – the funny foodie on Instagram, sarcastically mocked the Indian taxing system. Dressed in a saree to match the look of Sitharaman, Radha said in the video: "The GST Council has decided to include organ donation within the purview of GST. Now, anytime anyone donates or receives an organ, the surgery will be taxed at 18% GST." Copying the FM's style of clarification "for media speculations," the comedian said, "If you are in kidney failure, and you receive a kidney from somewhere...your life has been extended. That extension of life is what will come under GST." Radha joked that GST will apply to cornea donation and blood donation. "When the cornea is donated, a blind person receives a gift of sight...and gifts 'humesha se (since forever)' fall under GST. When you donate blood, you are giving something manufactured in your body using food, water, and oxygen, but you don't earn money from it. It will still come under the manufactured goods category. But to reduce the burden on the common man, the central government will take only 12% of the blood donated," she quipped.
In response to the huge social media backlash, the government, in the 55th GST council meeting, was forced to revert the tax on all popcorn in movie theatres back to 5%.
“Popcorn served loose in theatres is classified under ‘restaurant service’ and, as such, will remain taxed at 5%,” remarked an official. This case simply goes to show the power of social media in government policymaking. With the help of the internet and their unity, the Indian population could revert a law that seemed otherwise absurd and hilarious, just going to show the power of the people in a democracy.
Thank you for reading!